The nominees for the 91st Academy Awards have been announced, and comics fans’ kvetching and patience were finally rewarded as Black Panther received a nomination for Best Picture. While this is the first superhero movie to be so honored, it’s not the first comics character to score a Best Picture nod. Read on to discover the answer, and the myriad comics films which have been honored by the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences! (and overlooked by other websites discussing comics movies!) I’ve also included the rare films that use comics or the superhero genre as background for original stories, such as The Incredibles.
Here’s something to ponder… Will Black Panther be the first Marvel Cinematic Universe movie to win an Academy Award? (The losing streak is ten.) Or will it get snubbed, like another “colored” African-American movie?
CAVEAT: I say “almost definitive” because I created this list by reading the results for each awards show on Wikipedia, and then doing cursory research on the nominees for Foreign Film, Documentary categories, and short subjects. As always, if you discover an omission, please leave us a note below, and we will immediately regret the error.
Skippy, based on the comic strip by Percy Crosby, received the following nominations:
- Outstanding Production (It lost to Cimarron, a Western.)
- Best Director (Norman Taurog won. He was nominated again for Boys Town. For me, Dr. Goldfoot and the Bikini Machine is probably the most fun, although Elvis and Martin and Lewis fans might quibble.)
- Best Actor (Jackie Cooper, who many comics fans recognize as Perry White in the Superman movies.)
- Best Adaptation (Joseph L. Mankiewicz and Sam Mintz, based on the comic strip by Percy Crosby)
If you want something really truly bizarre, check out Just Imagine, a science fiction musical-comedy! It received a nomination for Best Art Direction.
A Boy Named Charlie Brown is nominated for Best Original Song Score. Music by Rod McKuen and John Scott Trotter; Lyrics by Rod McKuen, Bill Melendez, and Al Shean; Adapted by Vince Guaraldi (Yes, THAT Rod McKuen! Who did they lose to?)
Carnal Knowledge, written by Jules Feiffer, receives a nomination for Best Supporting Actress for Ann-Margaret.
It would later be the centerpiece of the Supreme Court obscenity ruling in Jenkins v. Georgia.
The Doonesbury Special by John Hubley, Faith Hubley and Garry Trudeau, received a nomination for Best Animated Short Film. It won the Grand Jury Prize from the Cannes Film Festival and was nominated for the Palme d’Or for “Best Short Film”.
- Best Film Editing (losing to The Deer Hunter)
- Best Music (Original Score) (a loss for John Williams, losing to Midnight Express and Giorgio Moroder)
- Best Sound (losing to The Deer Hunter)
- and a Special Achievement Academy Award for Visual Effects awarded to Les Bowie, Colin Chilvers, Denys Coop, Roy Field, Derek Meddings and Zoran Perisic
The Snowman, directed by John Coates, based on the graphic novel by Raymond Briggs, is nominated for Best Animated Short Film.
Annie, an adaptation of the musical based on the comic strip created Harold Gray, is nominated for two awards:
- Best Original Song Score and Its Adaptation or Adaptation Score: Adaptation Score by Ralph Burns
- Best Art Direction: Art Direction: Dale Hennesy (posthumous nomination); Set Decoration: Marvin March
Annie is the rare movie which also received Golden Raspberry Award nominations for numerous “worst” categories: Worst Picture, Worst Director (John Huston), Worst Screenplay (Carol Sobieski), and Worst New Star (Aileen Quinn). Ms. Quinn did win the award for Worst Supporting Actress. [I guess it wasn’t good, or bad, enough?]
- Best Makeup: Ve Neill, Ronnie Specter and Stan Winston
- Best Visual Effects: Michael L. Fink, Craig Barron, John Bruno and Dennis Skotak
Addams Family Values is nominated for Best Art Direction (Art Direction: Ken Adam; Set Decoration: Marvin March) but loses to Schindler’s List.
Scott Squires, Steve Spaz Williams, Tom Bertino and Jon Farhat are nominated for Best Visual Effects for their work on The Mask.
Batman Forever is nominated in three categories:
- Best Sound Effects Editing: John Leveque and Bruce Stambler (losing to Braveheart)
- Best Sound: Donald O. Mitchell, Frank A. Montaño, Michael Herbickand Petur Hliddal (losing to Apollo 13)
- Best Cinematography: Stephen Goldblatt (losing to Braveheart)
The Line King: The Al Hirschfeld Story, directed by Susan W. Dryfoos, is nominated for Best Documentary Feature
Men in Black earns three nominations, and wins one Oscar.
- Best Original Musical or Comedy Score: Danny Elfman loses to The Full Monty. [No, he was not nominated for his iconic Batman score.]
- Best Art Direction: Art Direction: Bo Welch; Set Decoration: Cheryl Carasik (Loss to Titanic.)
- Best Makeup: Rick Baker and David LeRoy Anderson win.
Ghost World , adapted by Daniel Clowes and Terry Zwigoff based on the comic book by Daniel Clowes, becomes the first comic book to be nominated for Best Screenplay Based on Material Previously Produced or Published/Adapted Screenplay. (Skippy, way up at the beginning of the list, was the first comic strip.)
The Road to Perdition earns six nominations and one win:
- Best Supporting Actor: Paul Newman lose to Chris Cooper in Adaptation.
- Best Original Score: Thomas Newman loses to Frida.
- Best Sound Editing: Scott Hecker loses to The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers
- Best Sound: Scott Millan, Bob Beemer, and John Patrick Pritchett lose to Chicago.
- Best Art Direction: Art Direction: Dennis Gassner; Set Decoration: Nancy Haigh, lose to Chicago.
- Best Cinematography: Conrad Hall wins the award posthumously.
Spider-Man receives two nominations:
- John Dykstra, Scott Stokdyk, Anthony LaMolinara, and John Frazier are nominated for Best Visual Effects.
- Kevin O’Connell, Greg P. Russell, and Ed Novick for Best Sound.
American Splendor receives a Best Adapted Screenplay nomination for Shari Springer Berman and Robert Pulcini based on the comic book series American Splendor by Harvey Pekar and Our Cancer Year by Harvey Pekar and Joyce Brabner.
The Incredibles receives four nominations, and wins two Oscars:
- Best Animated Feature Film: Brad Bird
- Best Sound Editing: Michael Silvers and Randy Thom
- Best Original Screenplay: Brad Bird loses to Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind.
- Best Sound Mixing: Randy Thom, Gary Rizzo and Doc Kane lose to Ray.
Spider-Man 2 receives three nominations, and wins one Oscar:
- Best Visual Effects: John Dykstra, Scott Stokdyk, Anthony LaMolinara and John Frazier
- Best Sound Editing: Paul N. J. Ottosson loses to The Incredibles.
- Best Sound Mixing: Kevin O’Connell, Greg P. Russell, Jeffrey J. Haboush and Joseph Geisinger lose to Ray.
Mark Stetson, Neil Corbould, Richard R. Hoover and Jon Thum receive a nomination for Best Visual Effects for Superman Returns.
- Best Supporting Actor: Heath Ledger – The Dark Knight as The Joker
- Best Sound Editing: Richard King
- Best Sound Mixing: Lora Hirschberg, Gary Rizzo and Ed Novick (losing to Slumdog Millionaire)
- Best Art Direction: Art Direction: Nathan Crowley; Set Decoration: Peter Lando (losing to The Curious Case of Benjamin Button)
- Best Cinematography : Wally Pfister (losing to Slumdog Millionaire).
- Best Makeup: John Caglione Jr. and Conor O’Sullivan (losing to The Curious Case of Benjamin Button)
- Best Film Editing: Lee Smith (losing to Slumdog Millionaire)
- Best Visual Effects: Nick Davis, Chris Corbould, Tim Webber and Paul Franklin (losing to The Curious Case of Benjamin Button)
Iron Man, the first Marvel Cinematic Universe movie, gains two nominations:
- Best Sound Editing: Frank Eulner and Christopher Boyes (losing to The Dark Knight)
- Best Visual Effects– John Nelson, Ben Snow, Dan Sudick and Shane Mahan (losing to The Curious Case of Benjamin Button)
Hellboy II: The Golden Army gains a Best Makeup nomination for Mike Elizalde and Thom Floutz.
Wanted earns a Best Sound Editing nomination for Wylie Stateman (he loses to The Dark Knight) and a Best Sound Mixing nomination for Chris Jenkins, Frank A. Montaño and Petr Forejt (who lose to Slumdog Millionaire ).
Iron Man 2 is nominated for Best Visual Effects by Janek Sirrs, Ben Snow, Ged Wright and Dan Sudick. They lose to Inception.
Christopher Townsend, Guy Williams, Erik Nash and Dan Sudick receive a Best Visual Effects nomination for their work on Iron Man 3, but lose to Gravity.
The Wind Rises, directed by Hayao Miyazaki and produced by Toshio Suzuki, receives a nomination for Best Animated Feature Film, losing to Frozen. According to Wikipedia, “The film is adapted from Miyazaki’s manga of the same name, which was in turn loosely based on both the 1937 novel The Wind Has Risen by Tatsuo Hori and the life of Jiro Horikoshi.”
Birdman or (The Unexpected Virtue of Ignorance) receives nine nominations, and wins four, including Best Picture and Best Director. Why mention it? Well, here’s the official synopsis from Fox Searchlight:
BIRDMAN or The Unexpected Virtue of Ignorance is a black comedy that tells the story of an actor (Michael Keaton) – famous for portraying an iconic superhero – as he struggles to mount a Broadway play. In the days leading up to opening night, he battles his ego and attempts to recover his family, his career, and himself.
Just sticking a pin in it, and moving on… [but, we fans of the last century loved this sort of thing… a comics poster seen in a sitcom, Bob Hope spoofing Batman and Robin, Spider-Man and His Amazing Friends… we were hungry for any notice or acceptance from mainstream media! Back then, comics fans were part of the Weird Nerd community, which included fans of Oingo Boingo, Hunter S. Thompson, and Night Flight. Now, Hollywood is chronic for comics! OOPS… looks like I added some red string to that pin. Sorry.]
Big Hero 6, based on the Marvel superheroes, is awarded Best Animated Feature Film. Don Hall, Chris Williams, and Roy Conli accept the award. [It would take three years for Disney to produce a spin-off TV series, and no further Disney-Marvel animated films have been announced. Perhaps Sony will drink Disney’s milkshake with Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse. Or maybe Disney will realize that animated features are a great way to showcase younger characters without the harsh realities seen in the MCU?]
[IT’S NOT A GENRE!!!]
Guardians of the Galaxy earns two nominations:
- Best Makeup and Hairstyling: Elizabeth Yianni-Georgiou and David Whit (losing to The Grand Budapest Hotel)
- Best Visual Effects: Stephane Ceretti, Nicolas Aithadi, Jonathan Fawkner, and Paul Corbould (losing to Interstellar)
Best Visual Effects lists three comic book movies among the five nominees:
- Captain America: The Winter Soldier – Dan DeLeeuw, Russell Earl, Bryan Grill, and Dan Sudick
- Guardians of the Galaxy – Stephane Ceretti, Nicolas Aithadi, Jonathan Fawkner, and Paul Corbould
- X-Men: Days of Future Past – Richard Stammers, Lou Pecora, Tim Crosbie, and Cameron Waldbauer
[The other two nominees are Dawn of the Planet of the Apes and the winner, Interstellar.]
Robert Valley and Cara Speller are nominated for Best Animated Short Film for Pear Cider and Cigarettes. Both the animated feature and the original graphic novels were financed via Kickstarter.
Alessandro Bertolazzi, Giorgio Gregorini and Christopher Nelson win the Oscar for Best Makeup and Hairstyling for their work on Suicide Squad.
Stephane Ceretti, Richard Bluff, Vincent Cirelli and Paul Corbould are nominated for Best Visual Effects for their work on Doctor Strange.
Logan is nominated for Best Adapted Screenplay, the first superhero comic book so honored. Screenplay by Scott Frank, James Mangold and Michael Green; Story by James Mangold based on characters created by Len Wein and John Romita Sr. [I don’t think Marvel officially credits them as the creators in the comics, nor pays them any equity fees.] Call Me by Your Name wins instead.
Christopher Townsend, Guy Williams, Jonathan Fawkner and Dan Sudick are nominated for Best Visual Effects for their work on Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2. Blade Runner 2049 wins the award.
- Best Picture
- Best Original Score
- Best Original Song [Competing with corporate cousin Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures.]
- Best Sound Editing
- Best Sound Mixing
- Best Production Design
- Best Costume Design
There are two superhero movies among the five nominees for Best Animated Feature Film:
- Incredibles 2
- Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse
Avengers: Infinity War is nominated for Best Visual Effects. If history is an indication, Marvel will lose this category, again.
I’ve been writing for The Beat since July of 2010.
I’ve been reading comics since 1974, collecting since 1984, and spreading the graphic novel gospel since 1994.
I’m a bookseller, a librarian, an amateur scholar, a cool uncle, and a comics evangelist.
Ask me anything!